Wednesday, March 09, 2005

Women in Science

There is some very interesting and disturbing research being done to look at how being a woman and being a mother effects one's ability to succeed in academia. I, of course, am particularly interested in those studies that address women in science. It will come to no surprise to most of you that women are at a disadvantage in their ability to get tenured faculty positions when compared to their male colleagues. I am going to attempt to give you a brief summary of the research out there that illustrates how much of a disadvantage it is.

There has been a sharp increase in the number of women receiving college degrees, particularly doctoral and professional degrees in the last couple of decades. The number of women with doctoral degrees in biological sciences has risen from 16.3% to 44.3% in the last 30 years. So the question is, are women finally achieving equality in academia? The answer is a very emphatic: NO!

Despite the dramatic increase in the number of women obtaining doctoral degrees, there has been only a modest increase in the number of women becoming tenured faculty. (This contradicts the argument proposed by some, that women are not as represented as men because they have only recently gained degrees in large numbers.) In a 2000 salary survey, it was reported that 48% of full-time faculty women are tenured, while 68% of full-time men have gained tenure. Instead of receiving tenured faculty position, women are much more likely to be found in non-tenure, often part-time, adjunct faculty positions. There is also a salary advantage held by male faculty members over female faculty at all ranks and institutional types. On average, women make only 88% of what there male colleagues are paid in academia.

So what is the cause of this trend? One major factor is that of having a family. While a job in the sciences is very time-consuming throughout, by far the most demanding time in the pursuit of a career in the academic sciences happens to fall right during the childbearing years. With graduate school in the 20s, post-doc in early 30s followed by the rigid 7 year tenure review period in the late 30s, there really is just no good time.

Women that have children within five years post-PhD (in biological sciences), are 24% less likely than men with children to achieve tenure at a 4 year university. Overall, women who do attain tenure are MUCH LESS likely to have children. 50% of tenured women faculty do not have children, whereas only 30% of men in the sciences do not have children. It is obvious that women in science have to make difficult life choices in order to successfully pursue a career in academia.

I could go on and on about the statistics, but what may be a better use of my effort would be what I think should be done about this problem (hopefully I've convinced you that there is a problem). Some institutions are taking steps to make a career in academia more compatible with having a family. Many institutions have adopted some of the recommendations I am about to address, but none (to my knowledge) has put all of them into effect.

Recommendations (made by me and my references):
1. Pregnancy leave (paid would be nice)
2. Family-care leave
3. Emergency-care and other short-term leave
4. Active service with modified duties
5. Stopping the tenure clock for childbirth
6. Child care
7. Flexible work policies and schedules
8. Part-time track and re-entry rights
9. Discounting of the "resume gap"


Most of these recommendations deal with time issues. One popular recommendation is that of "stopping the tenure clock" which enables tenure track faculty to gain an additional year to obtain tenure if they have a newborn or newly adopted child during the 7 year tenure review process. In addition, allowing faculty to go on a modified/reduced workload for up to a year would also be helpful. This would mean reduced teaching and adminstrative responsibilities but still enables the faculty member to mentor their graduate students and continue research. Providing ON-SITE childcare is also crucial in my opinion. These recommendations also attempt to address the problem of women getting stuck in adjunct and part-time teaching positions. Why not make a track that allows an adjunct/part-time faculty to move into a full-time, tenure track position after a period of time, say 5 years? This would allow for flexibility for the childhood years, but still allow woman faculty to have a career once their children are entering school.

Of course, these recommendation really do nothing for those women that drop away before taking a tenure track position. While many of these policies can and should be applied to graduate students and postdocs, most aren't. Although, I must say, here at Berkeley, they allow us to take a 1 year leave of absence (for any reason) and then return to the graduate program. Such a student would also likely receive additional time and funding to complete their thesis work. However this is unpaid leave, there is no subsidized childcare, let alone on-site childcare offered and because we are not really employees, graduate students don't even get "disability" pay for maternity leave.

In summary, much can be done to address this issue of inequality. Is it going to be easy? No. Is it going to be cheap? No. But it will be worth it. There are so many women out there that are talented individuals, even top of their field that are kept from reaching their full potential because they want to have a family too. We need to do more to help these women in their careers.

Recommended Reading/References:
Do Babies Matter?
Do Babies Matter Part 2?
Women Faculty Seeking Tenure and Parenthood

The Potential To Develop A Career In Science

No comments: